79. Growing Up

Last week, you may have read my article about permissiveness/limit-setting. George Bush once got some laughs by announcing that he didn’t have to eat broccoli any more because he was President of the United States. I do like broccoli, and I’m not a Republican, but the guy did have a point. I sometimes don’t clear the breakfast dishes off the table until dinner time; I’m almost forty-eight years old, and no one can make me.
My parents seem to have accepted the fact that I am in control of my life, and I think I realize that my daughters are in control of their lives. But neither realization came easily. The
transition from the role of limit-setter to the role of serene, unobtrusive consultant can be rough. There are some parents who do it gracefully, but in my experience, most don’t.
Pre-adolescence and adolescence are the years when the transition is roughest. It sometimes seems to our daughters and sons that we see them as adults when it’s convenient for us. And to us, it seems as if they want to be treated as adults when it suits them. The same person who says, “I’m fourteen! I should be allowed to decide for myself!” may later say, “Come on! I’m only fourteen!”
Many cultures have rites of passage that indicate when a child becomes an adult. Mine defined me as a man at age thirteen. But I was somewhere in my late twenties when I started feeling that the definition really applied to me. I still forget sometimes. I’m going to a friend’s bat mitzvah soon (I almost wrote “two friends’ daughter’s bat mitzvah”) and I wonder at what point she will see herself as a woman.
When our children are young, their moves toward independence are more likely to delight us. The moment when the child learns where to excrete. The tying of the shoelaces. The first book read independently. We feel that we are doing it all right – we created or adopted and nurtured a human being, and we are doing our part to help build the future.
It’s not as easy to rejoice about some of the later milestones. For a while, I think I was unconsciously angry at my daughters for destroying the little children they once were, by growing up. I think my parents probably had similar difficulty seeing their children grow up. Now, when one of my daughters comes to visit, I see the child in her, see the adult, and love the person. Sometimes, I make a suggestion. That’s all. And she does the driving; I’m not as good a driver as I used to be.

Similar Posts

  • 300. New Math

    Now, as I write article #300, I’m remembering an experiment that was introduced to schools. Early in my teaching career, there was something called “new math.” It wasn’t really so new, but it was new in the elementary curriculum. The basic premise, I think, was that children shouldn’t learn to be stuck in base ten….

  • 24. Reading Buddies

    Margaret Mead described an aspect of Samoan culture that seemed downright utopian: growing up without adolescence. Children helped to raise their siblings, and the various traumas of pre-adolescence and adolescence didn’t happen. There was no niche in the culture for it. I caught a glimpse of that utopia when I saw “reading buddies” at work…

  • 203. Abstract and Concrete

    Piaget worked hard to learn about children’s learning, and though I try to avoid worshipping people, Piaget is high up there on my list. But today I found myself taking another look at a dichotomy he’d analyzed. I’d read The Origin of Intelligence in Children, and Play, Dreams, and Imitation in Childhood. I’d considered Piaget’s…

  • 368. Rhyme

    Have you ever wondered why none of my articles rhyme? I know how to rhyme; if I wanted to rhyme them I could. But rhyming plays games with the mind; I’m afraid if I did, you’d think I was fooling around, and that wouldn’t be good. I want you to read what I write and…